Why do my color grades always suck? Today I'm answering that. And I realize the title is a bit harsh, whether you like a grade is subjective, so these are just things I notice in other people's grades that I think could be improved. Here are five of the big ones.
01Your subject's skin color is inaccurate
This is the one I see most, and it's the most important. No matter how great the rest of your shot looks, off-color skin kills the whole grade. You can stylize a ton and get away with it, as long as the skin stays accurate, because we look at people's skin all day and we instantly sense when it's off. Fix it during the color correction phase so stylizing is easier later. Crop into your subject's skin with the inspector crop sliders, open your Vectorscope (Command 7), and check it against the skin tone line, skin should fall right on that line no matter the natural complexion. If it's off, open a hue/sat curve and nudge the master slider until the skin sits on the line, then toggle the crop back off. Already stylized and your skin drifted? Remember skin lives in the midtones, so push your midtones with the color wheels or color curves until it's back on the line (hold Shift + Option for a slower, on-axis curve adjustment).
02Not enough color separation
Without getting deep into color theory, your subject and your background should be distinct enough that the eye knows where to look. Pushing your subject and background toward complementary colors (like the classic teal background with warm skin) creates that separation and instantly makes a shot feel more intentional.
03Your white balance is off
If your whites aren't actually white, everything downstream is fighting a bad starting point, and it usually drags your skin tones off with it. Correct your white balance first, using a white or gray reference in the frame, before you touch anything creative.
04Blown highlights and crushed blacks
Clipping your highlights past 100 IRE or crushing your blacks below 0 throws away detail you can never get back. Expand your dynamic range, but keep everything at appropriate levels, watch your luma waveform and don't let the brightest and darkest parts slam into the edges.
05Too much saturation
Over-saturating is an easy trap, and it works against you: when everything's screaming with color, the viewer loses focus on what's actually important in the frame. Pull it back until the color supports the shot instead of overwhelming it. And one bonus reason, make sure your grade actually fits the mood and style of your video, a look that's gorgeous on its own can still be wrong for the story you're telling.
Build a real color workflow in FCP
The FCP Color Grading Masterclass is a full professional color course for Final Cut Pro, featured on Apple's official FCP Resources page.
Explore the Masterclass